Proofs of false statements

Mark Dominus brought up an interesting question last month: have there been major screw-ups in mathematics? He defines a “major screw-up” to be a flawed proof of an incorrect statement that was accepted for a significant period of time. He excludes the case of incorrect proofs of statements that were nevertheless true.

It’s remarkable that he can even ask the question. Can you imagine someone asking with a straight face whether there have ever been major screw-ups in, say, software development? And yet it takes some hard thought to come up with examples of really big blunders in math.

No doubt there are plenty of flawed proofs of false statements in areas too obscure for anyone to care about. But in mainstream areas of math, blunders are usually uncovered very quickly. And there are examples of theorems that were essentially correct but neglected some edge case. Proofs of statements that are just plain wrong are hard to think of. But Mark Dominus came up with a few.

Yesterday he gave an example of a statement by Kurt Gödel that was flat-out wrong but accepted for over 30 years. Warning: reader discretion advised. His post is not suitable for those who get queasy at the sight of symbolic logic.

64 Responses to “Proofs of false statements”

  1. Alexander7 says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.trustedpillspot.com/?ml=buy-generic-LEVITRA buy@generic.LEVITRA” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Need cheap generic LEVITRA?…

  2. SETH says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium2732/biography/?ml=Order-Cheap-Coral-Calcium Order@Cheap.Coral.Calcium” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric pills…

  3. BRANDON says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium2921/biography/?ml=Order-Discount-Coral-Calcium Order@Discount.Coral.Calcium” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyno prescription…

  4. LEWIS says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify3021/biography/?ml=Purchase-Cheap-Abilify Purchase@Cheap.Abilify” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buynow it…

  5. RENE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium2080/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Coral.Calcium.Online” >.< /a >…

    Buygeneric drugs…

  6. SALVADOR says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/coral_calcium2921/biography/?ml=Order-Discount-Coral-Calcium Order@Discount.Coral.Calcium” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric meds…

  7. PERRY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abana6720/biography/?ml=Purchase-Cheap-Abana Purchase@Cheap.Abana” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buywithout prescription…

  8. SAMUEL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai8936/biography/?ml=Buy-Cheap-Acai Buy@Cheap.Acai” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs…

  9. FELIX says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai7722/biography/?ml=Purchase-Cheap-Acai Purchase@Cheap.Acai” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyit now…

  10. KELLY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai9030/biography/?ml=Cheap-Acai-Online Cheap@Acai.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric meds…

  11. MATHEW says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accutane1980/biography/?ml=1 Order@Discount.Accutane” >.< /a >…

    Buyno prescription…

  12. CARL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex3137/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Generic.Aciphex” >.< /a >…

    Buygeneric meds…

  13. NATHAN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex3902/biography/?ml=1 Purchase@Generic.Aciphex.20mg” >.< /a >…

    Buynow it…

  14. BILLY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actonel5424/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Generic.Actonel” >.< /a >…

    Buygeneric drugs…

  15. RUBEN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actonel7445/biography/?ml=1 Buy@Generic.Actonel.Without.Prescription” >.< /a >…

    Buygeneric meds…

  16. JONATHAN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actonel2292/biography/?ml=Purchase-Generic-Actonel Purchase@Generic.Actonel” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric meds vbg…

  17. MARCUS says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actonel4576/biography/?ml=Purchase-Actonel-Without-Prescription Purchase@Actonel.Without.Prescription” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buynow it vhx…

  18. DARYL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/actoplus_met5682/biography/?ml=Buy-Actoplus-Met-Online Buy@Actoplus.Met.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs krg…

  19. RAY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abana8356/biography/?ml=Buy-Discount-Abana Buy@Discount.Abana” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs zfk…

  20. LAWRENCE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify8423/biography/?ml=Purchase-Discount-Abilify Purchase@Discount.Abilify” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buywithout prescription dyo…

  21. MITCHELL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/abilify5105/biography/?ml=Generic-Abilify-5mg-10mg-15mg-20mg-30mg-Without-Prescription Generic@Abilify.5mg.10mg.15mg.20mg.30mg.Without.Prescription” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buydrugs without prescription faj…

  22. VINCENT says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai4417/biography/?ml=Purchase-Acai-Online Purchase@Acai.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyit now ojb…

  23. BRYAN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acai3744/biography/?ml=Buy-Generic-Acai-500mg Buy@Generic.Acai.500mg” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs nih…

  24. HOMER says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accupril1614/biography/?ml=Purchase-Cheap-Accupril Purchase@Cheap.Accupril” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyit now irl…

  25. PHILIP says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accupril1097/biography/?ml=Purchase-Discount-Accupril Purchase@Discount.Accupril” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric meds svb…

  26. MARVIN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/accutane2130/biography/?ml=Cheap-Accutane-Online Cheap@Accutane.Online” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buynow it lmg…

  27. BRUCE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/aciphex193/biography/?ml=Cheap-Generic-Aciphex-20mg Cheap@Generic.Aciphex.20mg” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buynow it zdg…

  28. JOEL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acomplia2182/biography/?ml=Buy-Acomplia-Online Buy@Acomplia.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyno prescription wkp…

  29. CHRIS says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/acomplia9432/biography/?ml=Cheap-Acomplia-Online Cheap@Acomplia.Online” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs nvr…

  30. STEVE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://trig.com/albenza4309/biography/?ml=Get-Albenza-Online Get@Albenza.Online” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buynow fjl…

  31. BRENT says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.box.net/view_shared/a9dcn12e7o?ml=id abilify@and.weight.gain” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buyno prescription…

  32. OLIVER says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.box.net/view_shared/9a3hgo2zmc?ml=id phamacokinetic@of.amikacin” >..< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric drugs…

  33. MARTIN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.box.net/view_shared/779h5yb7fn?ml=id ampicillin@500.mg” >.< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buydrugs without prescription…

  34. LESTER says:

    < b >< a href=”http://eltcommunity.com/elt/bookmarks/1147?decorator=print#comments” >methotrexate and tricyclerides side effects< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic pills…

  35. LUIS says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.music123.com/bookmarks/1129?decorator=print#comments” >cancer tattoos< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_without prescription…

  36. AUSTIN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.harmonycentral.com/bookmarks/4416?decorator=print#comments” >obesity children summer< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_it now…

  37. NICK says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.techweb.com/bookmarks/2388?decorator=print#comments” >prostate cancer injection treatment< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_now it…

  38. DON says:

    < b >< a href=”http://communities.netapp.com/bookmarks/2134?decorator=print#comments” >medication for ibs< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic drugs…

  39. ENRIQUE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.techweb.com/bookmarks/2584?decorator=print#comments” >effects of bulimia only sometimes< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic meds…

  40. JESSIE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.protocolexchange.com/bookmarks/1549?decorator=print#comments” >boniva price< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_drugs without prescription…

  41. COREY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.landesk.com/support/bookmarks/2038?decorator=print#comments” >australia clinical research resume< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic drugs…

  42. KENT says:

    < b >< a href=”http://beta.hopestreetgroup.org/bookmarks/3252?decorator=print#comments” >tests for assessing anxiety< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_now it…

  43. GERALD says:

    < b >< a href=”http://beta.hopestreetgroup.org/bookmarks/3289?decorator=print#comments” >thyroid scan image< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic pills…

  44. JACOB says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.crn.com/bookmarks/1892?decorator=print#comments” >side effects of luvox< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_now…

  45. TED says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/2123?decorator=print#comments” >tylenol without codeine related constipation< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_it now…

  46. WAYNE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.protocolexchange.com/bookmarks/1956?decorator=print#comments” >advantage of skin cancer< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic drugs…

  47. AUSTIN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.protocolexchange.com/bookmarks/1959?decorator=print#comments” >negative thyroid test< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_no prescription…

  48. ELMER says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/2249?decorator=print#comments” >household chemicals that kill fleas< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_now it…

  49. JOEY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://enterpriseleadership.org/bookmarks/2222?decorator=print#comments” >atkins diet first week foods< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_without prescription…

  50. GUY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://policy2.org/bookmarks/4373?decorator=print#comments” >fungi amazing facts< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_drugs without prescription…

  51. LUKE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://beta.hopestreetgroup.org/bookmarks/4646?decorator=print#comments” >dog hives and what causes them< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_drugs without prescription…

  52. KYLE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.protocolexchange.com/bookmarks/2188?decorator=print#comments” >depression amino acids< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_drugs without prescription…

  53. RAY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://solid.community.appliedbiosystems.com/bookmarks/2277?decorator=print#comments” >best drug store foundation< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic meds…

  54. RANDALL says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.lls.org/bookmarks/2741?decorator=print#comments” >when develop toxemia pregnancy< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_it now…

  55. LOUIS says:

    < b >< a href=”http://policy2.org/bookmarks/5088?decorator=print#comments” >acne teens start treatment age< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_it now…

  56. LYNN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/2485?decorator=print#comments” >period changes leading up to menopause< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_it now…

  57. EDWIN says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.harmonycentral.com/bookmarks/6277?decorator=print#comments” >drug additiction symptoms< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic meds…

  58. ALFRED says:

    < b >< a href=”http://communities.leviton.com/bookmarks/3416?decorator=print#comments” >new birth control pill< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_now it…

  59. MILTON says:

    < b >< a href=”http://eltcommunity.com/elt/bookmarks/2695?decorator=print#comments” >zocor orange juice effects< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_no prescription…

  60. FREDDIE says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.screwfix.com/community/bookmarks/2824?decorator=print#comments” >childrens ibuprofen diabetes< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_without prescription…

  61. DONALD says:

    < b >< a href=”http://community.crn.com/bookmarks/2855?decorator=print#comments” >tsa drug dogs for adoptino< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic drugs…

  62. JIMMY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://eltcommunity.com/elt/bookmarks/2848?decorator=print#comments” >barbecue interactions with drugs< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buy_generic meds…

  63. STANLEY says:

    < b >< a href=”http://www.box.net/view_shared/ybjbyyvmd6?ml=id green@mountain.coffee.cafe.club” >…< /a >< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Buygeneric meds…

  64. JACK says:

    < blockquote > GENERIC PHARMACY : < b >-==== < a href=”http://pillsspot.comsyhost.com/order_respiratory_en-us.html” >Respiratory Cure < /a > ====-< /b >< /blockquote >…

    Order Good Generic Drugs Today!…